Both the men's and women's teams from Luther College were tabbed as All-Academic Teams, as were the women's teams from Simpson College and Wartburg College. Of the 18 individuals, ten (five men, five women) are from Luther, while another seven (four women, three men) come from Wartburg. A pair of women's players from Simpson round out the list of ITA Scholar Athletes from the Iowa Conference.

The ITA All-Academic Team award is open to any ITA program that has a cumulative team grade point average of 3.20 or above (on a 4.00 scale). All eligible student-athletes whose names appear on the NCAA/NAIA/NJCAA/CA JUCO eligibility form and have competed in one or more varsity matches must average into the GPA for the current academic year (including fall 2009 and spring 2010).

In order to earn ITA Scholar-Athlete status a player must meet the following criteria: 1.) be a varsity letter winner, 2.) have a grade point average of at least 3.50 (on a 4.00 scale) for the current academic year, and 3.) have been enrolled at their present school for at least 2 semesters (including freshman thorough senior year).

Complete list of NCAA Division III men's ITA All-Academic Teams & Scholar-Athletes