| | | Simpson wins toss, defers. |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw35 | SIM ball on SIM30. |
| | | Bill Nelson kickoff 55 yards to the CUW15, Kasiem Duran return 15 yards to the CUW30 (Austyn Wolfe;Kasey Bean). |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw30 | Chris Clarke rush for 3 yards to the CUW33 (Ben Pruss;Lucas Kramer). |
| Cuw | 2-7 | at Cuw33 | Chris Clarke rush for 1 yard to the CUW34 (Tanner Tracy;Jason Courtney). |
| Cuw | 3-6 | at Cuw34 | Thomas Pacchiol pass complete to Ricardo Levy for 7 yards to the CUW41, 1ST DOWN CUW, out-of-bounds. |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw41 | David White rush for 2 yards to the CUW43 (Blair Belland;Tim Stover). |
| Cuw | 2-8 | at Cuw43 | Thomas Pacchiol pass incomplete to Chris Clarke. |
| Cuw | 3-8 | at Cuw43 | Thomas Pacchiol pass incomplete to Taylor Siolka. |
| Cuw | 4-8 | at Cuw43 | Tom Roberts punt 39 yards to the SIM18, Trent Kain return 20 yards to the SIM38 (Preston Jezek;Ryan Bott). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 13 yards, TOP 02:28 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim38 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 12:32. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim38 | Adam Reutzel rush for 1 yard to the SIM39 (Jason Lawrence;Justin Rindt). |
| Sim | 2-9 | at Sim39 | Travis Unkrich pass incomplete to Brody Tubaugh. |
| Sim | 3-9 | at Sim39 | Travis Unkrich pass complete to Brody Tubaugh for no gain to the SIM39 (Nick Napoli). |
| Sim | 4-9 | at Sim39 | Bill Nelson punt 61 yards to the CUW0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 1 yards, TOP 01:31 |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw20 | CONCORDIA UNIV. (WI) drive start at 11:01. |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw20 | David White rush for 1 yard to the CUW21 (Tanner Tracy;Jason Courtney). |
| Cuw | 2-9 | at Cuw21 | Thomas Pacchiol pass complete to Ricardo Levy for 1 yard to the CUW22 (Drew Lipovac). |
| Cuw | 3-8 | at Cuw22 | Thomas Pacchiol pass intercepted by Lucas Kramer at the CUW30, Lucas Kramer return 5 yards to the CUW25 (Taylor Siolka). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 2 yards, TOP 01:24 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Cuw25 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 09:37. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Cuw25 | Adam Reutzel rush for no gain to the CUW25 (Justin Rindt;Travis Pagel), PENALTY SIM false start 5 yards to the CUW30, NO PLAY. |
| Sim | 1-15 | at Cuw30 | Adam Reutzel rush for 2 yards to the CUW28 (Justin Rindt). |
| Sim | 2-13 | at Cuw28 | Travis Unkrich pass incomplete to Mack Kimble. |
| Sim | 3-13 | at Cuw28 | Travis Unkrich pass complete to Adam Reutzel for 28 yards to the CUW0, 1ST DOWN SIM, TOUCHDOWN, clock 08:38. |
| | | Bill Nelson kick attempt good. |
| | | Simpson College 7, Concordia Univ. (WI) 0 |
| Sim | 1-G | at Sim35 | SIM ball on SIM30. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 25 yards, TOP 00:59 |
| | | Bill Nelson kickoff 65 yards to the CUW5, Ricardo Levy return 41 yards to the CUW46 (Bill Nelson). |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw46 | CONCORDIA UNIV. (WI) drive start at 08:31. |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw46 | David White rush for no gain to the CUW46 (Jason Courtney;Ben Pruss). |
| Cuw | 2-10 | at Cuw46 | Thomas Pacchiol pass complete to Taylor Siolka for 12 yards to the SIM42, 1ST DOWN CUW. |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Sim42 | David White rush for 8 yards to the SIM34 (Kyle Disney). |
| Cuw | 2-2 | at Sim34 | David White rush for no gain to the SIM34 (Jason Courtney). |
| Cuw | 3-2 | at Sim34 | Thomas Pacchiol pass complete to Taylor Siolka for 5 yards to the SIM29, 1ST DOWN CUW (Jeff Wilkins;Neil Bontrager). |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Sim29 | David White rush for loss of 2 yards to the SIM31 (Tim Stover). |
| Cuw | 2-12 | at Sim31 | Thomas Pacchiol pass intercepted by Tim Stover at the SIM12, Tim Stover return 24 yards to the SIM36 (Taylor Siolka). |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 23 yards, TOP 03:15 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim36 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 05:16. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim36 | Sean Maudlin rush for 4 yards to the SIM40 (Justin Rindt). |
| Sim | 2-6 | at Sim40 | Travis Unkrich pass complete to Trent Kain for 5 yards to the SIM45 (Preston Jezek). |
| Sim | 3-1 | at Sim45 | Sean Maudlin rush for no gain to the SIM45 (Ryan Bott;B. Williams). |
| Sim | 4-1 | at Sim45 | Bill Nelson punt 47 yards to the CUW8, Dontrell Hall return 25 yards to the CUW33, out-of-bounds (Tim Stover;Brody Tubaugh). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 9 yards, TOP 02:20 |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw33 | CONCORDIA UNIV. (WI) drive start at 02:56. |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw33 | Justin Lewis pass incomplete to Ricardo Levy. |
| Cuw | 2-10 | at Cuw33 | Justin Lewis pass incomplete to Kristopher Zemb. |
| Cuw | 3-10 | at Cuw33 | Justin Lewis pass incomplete to Taylor Siolka. |
| Cuw | 4-10 | at Cuw33 | Tom Roberts punt 42 yards to the SIM25, Trent Kain return 0 yards to the SIM25, fumble by Trent Kain recovered by SIM Tim Stover at SIM31. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:25 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim31 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 02:31, SIM ball on SIM31. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim31 | Adam Reutzel rush for 4 yards to the SIM35, out-of-bounds (Jacob Lautenbac;Kyle Stouff). |
| Sim | 2-6 | at Sim35 | Travis Unkrich pass complete to Mack Kimble for 5 yards to the SIM40 (Preston Jezek). |
| Sim | 3-1 | at Sim40 | Aaron White rush for 3 yards to the SIM43, 1ST DOWN SIM (Justin Rindt;Travis Pagel). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim43 | Travis Unkrich pass incomplete to Aaron White. |
| Sim | 2-10 | at Sim43 | Adam Reutzel rush for 6 yards to the SIM49 (Ryan Bott;Jason Lawrence). |
| Sim | 3-4 | at Sim49 | Travis Unkrich pass incomplete to Adam Reutzel (Jacob Lautenbac). |
| Sim | 4-4 | at Sim49 | Bill Nelson punt 42 yards to the CUW9, Dontrell Hall return -2 yards to the CUW7 (Cody Jensen;Aaron White). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 18 yards, TOP 02:16 |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw07 | CONCORDIA UNIV. (WI) drive start at 00:15. |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw07 | David White rush for no gain to the CUW7 (Tanner Tracy;Tim Stover). |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 0 yards, TOP 03:03 |
| | | Simpson College 7, Concordia Univ. (WI) 0 |
| Cuw | 2-10 | at Cuw07 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Cuw | 2-10 | at Cuw07 | Justin Lewis pass complete to Mike Jolin for 9 yards to the CUW16 (Drew Lipovac;Tim Stover). |
| Cuw | 3-1 | at Cuw16 | David White rush for 3 yards to the CUW19, 1ST DOWN CUW (Tim Stover;Blair Belland). |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw19 | Taylor Siolka rush for 3 yards to the CUW22 (Tim Stover;Neil Bontrager). |
| Cuw | 2-7 | at Cuw22 | David White rush for loss of 1 yard to the CUW21 (Tanner Tracy). |
| Cuw | 3-8 | at Cuw21 | PENALTY CUW substitution infraction 5 yards to the CUW16. |
| Cuw | 3-13 | at Cuw16 | Justin Lewis pass incomplete to Ricardo Levy (Luke Stover). |
| Cuw | 4-13 | at Cuw16 | Tom Roberts punt 49 yards to the SIM35, Trent Kain return -21 yards to the SIM14, fumble by Trent Kain recovered by SIM Trent Kain at SIM9. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 9 yards, TOP 03:03 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim09 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 12:12, SIM ball on SIM9. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim09 | Sean Maudlin rush for no gain to the SIM9 (Travis Pagel;Justin Rindt). |
| Sim | 2-10 | at Sim09 | Adam Reutzel rush for 6 yards to the SIM15 (Travis Pagel;Adam Schultz). |
| Sim | 3-4 | at Sim15 | Sean Maudlin rush for no gain to the SIM15, fumble by Sean Maudlin recovered by CUW Jacob Lautenbac at SIM13. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 4 yards, TOP 01:26 |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Sim13 | CONCORDIA UNIV. (WI) drive start at 10:46. |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Sim13 | Chris Clarke rush for no gain to the SIM13 (Tanner Tracy;Neil Bontrager). |
| Cuw | 2-10 | at Sim13 | Justin Lewis pass incomplete to Taylor Siolka. |
| Cuw | 3-10 | at Sim13 | Justin Lewis sacked for loss of 9 yards to the SIM22 (Blair Belland). |
| Cuw | 4-19 | at Sim22 | Dan Winsey field goal attempt from 39 GOOD, clock 09:09. |
| | | Simpson College 7, Concordia Univ. (WI) 3 |
| Cuw | 1-G | at Cuw35 | CUW ball on CUW30. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, minus 9 yards, TOP 01:37 |
| | | Dan Winsey kickoff 68 yards to the SIM2, Mack Kimble return 18 yards to the SIM20 (Michael Haslam;Mike Jolin). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim20 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 09:00. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim20 | Travis Dietz rush for 1 yard to the SIM21 (Travis Pagel;Jason Lawrence). |
| Sim | 2-9 | at Sim21 | Travis Dietz pass incomplete to Mack Kimble. |
| Sim | 3-9 | at Sim21 | Travis Dietz pass complete to Adam Reutzel for no gain to the SIM21, fumble by Adam Reutzel recovered by SIM Adam Reutzel at SIM21, PENALTY SIM holding declined. |
| Sim | 4-9 | at Sim21 | Bill Nelson punt 35 yards to the CUW44, fair catch by Dontrell Hall. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 1 yards, TOP 01:15 |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw44 | CONCORDIA UNIV. (WI) drive start at 07:45. |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw44 | David White rush for 8 yards to the SIM48 (Antonio Neal). |
| Cuw | 2-2 | at Sim48 | Thomas Pacchiol pass incomplete to Chris Clarke (Drew Lipovac), PENALTY CUW holding 10 yards to the CUW42, NO PLAY. |
| Cuw | 2-12 | at Cuw42 | Thomas Pacchiol rush for 9 yards to the SIM49 (Neil Bontrager), PENALTY CUW holding 10 yards to the CUW32, NO PLAY. |
| Cuw | 2-22 | at Cuw32 | Timeout Concordia Univ. (WI), clock 06:57. |
| Cuw | 2-22 | at Cuw32 | Thomas Pacchiol pass incomplete. |
| Cuw | 3-22 | at Cuw32 | Thomas Pacchiol pass incomplete to Taylor Siolka. |
| Cuw | 4-22 | at Cuw32 | Tom Roberts punt 34 yards to the SIM34, fair catch by Trent Kain. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 12 yards, TOP 01:15 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim34 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 06:30. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim34 | Sean Maudlin rush for 5 yards to the SIM39 (Kyle Stouff;Ryan Bott). |
| Sim | 2-5 | at Sim39 | Travis Unkrich pass incomplete to Brody Tubaugh. |
| Sim | 3-5 | at Sim39 | Travis Unkrich pass complete to Mack Kimble for 15 yards to the CUW46, 1ST DOWN SIM, out-of-bounds (Jacob Lautenbac). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Cuw46 | Travis Unkrich pass incomplete to Trent Kain (Dontrell Hall). |
| Sim | 2-10 | at Cuw46 | Travis Unkrich pass complete to Trent Kain for 9 yards to the CUW37 (Kyle Stouff;Jacob Lautenbac). |
| Sim | 3-1 | at Cuw37 | Aaron White rush for 2 yards to the CUW35 (Jacob Lautenbac), PENALTY CUW offside 5 yards to the CUW32, 1ST DOWN SIM, NO PLAY. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Cuw32 | Adam Reutzel rush for 3 yards to the CUW29 (Justin Rindt). |
| Sim | 2-7 | at Cuw29 | Adam Reutzel rush for no gain to the CUW29 (Travis Pagel;Ryan Bott). |
| Sim | 3-7 | at Cuw29 | Adam Reutzel rush for 4 yards to the CUW25 (Nick Napoli). |
| Sim | 4-3 | at Cuw25 | Bill Nelson field goal attempt from 41 MISSED - hit right upright, spot at CUW25, clock 02:28. |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 41 yards, TOP 04:37 |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw25 | Justin Lewis rush for 8 yards to the CUW33 (Tim Stover). |
| Cuw | 2-2 | at Cuw33 | Justin Lewis pass complete to Taylor Siolka for 7 yards to the CUW40, fumble forced by Neil Bontrager, fumble by Taylor Siolka recovered by SIM Lucas Kramer at CUW38. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 13 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Cuw38 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 01:53. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Cuw38 | Travis Unkrich rush for 4 yards to the CUW34 (Jason Lawrence;Nick Napoli). |
| Sim | 2-6 | at Cuw34 | Travis Unkrich pass complete to Trent Kain for 6 yards to the CUW28, 1ST DOWN SIM, out-of-bounds (Dontrell Hall). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Cuw28 | Travis Unkrich pass complete to Trent Kain for 28 yards to the CUW0, 1ST DOWN SIM, TOUCHDOWN, clock 01:16. |
| | | Bill Nelson kick attempt good. |
| | | Simpson College 14, Concordia Univ. (WI) 3 |
| Sim | 1-G | at Sim35 | SIM ball on SIM30. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 38 yards, TOP 00:37 |
| | | Bill Nelson kickoff 55 yards to the CUW15, Kasiem Duran return 14 yards to the CUW29 (Jeff Wilkins). |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw29 | CONCORDIA UNIV. (WI) drive start at 01:10. |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw29 | PENALTY CUW false start 5 yards to the CUW24. |
| Cuw | 1-15 | at Cuw24 | Justin Lewis pass incomplete to Chris Clarke (Lucas Kramer), QB hurry by Ben Reutzel. |
| Cuw | 2-15 | at Cuw24 | David White rush for no gain to the CUW24 (Ben Reutzel;Tanner Tracy). |
| Cuw | 3-15 | at Cuw24 | Timeout Concordia Univ. (WI), clock 00:59. |
| Cuw | 3-15 | at Cuw24 | David White rush for 2 yards to the CUW26 (Tanner Tracy). |
| Cuw | 4-13 | at Cuw26 | Timeout Simpson College, clock 00:54. |
| Cuw | 4-13 | at Cuw26 | Tom Roberts punt 55 yards to the SIM19, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 3 yards, TOP 00:31 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim19 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 00:39. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim19 | Travis Unkrich pass complete to Trent Kain for 1 yard to the SIM20 (Kyle Stouff). |
| Sim | 2-9 | at Sim20 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 1 yards, TOP 00:39 |
| | | Simpson College 14, Concordia Univ. (WI) 3 |
| Sim | 2-9 | at Sim20 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, CUW ball on CUW30. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 1 yards, TOP 00:39 |
| | | Dan Winsey kickoff 62 yards to the SIM8, Mack Kimble return 26 yards to the SIM34 (Justin Tlachac). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim34 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 14:52. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim34 | Adam Reutzel rush for no gain to the SIM34 (Justin Rindt;Travis Pagel). |
| Sim | 2-10 | at Sim34 | Adam Reutzel rush for 6 yards to the SIM40 (Jason Lawrence;Jacob Lautenbac). |
| Sim | 3-4 | at Sim40 | Travis Unkrich pass incomplete to Mack Kimble. |
| Sim | 4-4 | at Sim40 | Bill Nelson punt 34 yards to the CUW26, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 6 yards, TOP 01:32 |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw26 | CONCORDIA UNIV. (WI) drive start at 13:20. |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw26 | Jerome Walker rush for loss of 2 yards to the CUW24 (Jason Courtney;Tim Stover). |
| Cuw | 2-12 | at Cuw24 | Thomas Pacchiol pass incomplete to Taylor Siolka. |
| Cuw | 3-12 | at Cuw24 | Thomas Pacchiol pass complete to Mike Jolin for 10 yards to the CUW34 (Lucas Kramer). |
| Cuw | 4-2 | at Cuw34 | Tom Roberts punt 47 yards to the SIM19, fair catch by Trent Kain. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 8 yards, TOP 01:37 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim19 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 11:43. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim19 | Sean Maudlin rush for 2 yards to the SIM21 (Nick Napoli;Kyle Stouff). |
| Sim | 2-8 | at Sim21 | Sean Maudlin rush for 9 yards to the SIM30, 1ST DOWN SIM (Jacob Lautenbac;Kyle Stouff). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim30 | Travis Unkrich rush for 1 yard to the SIM31 (Ryan Bott;Jason Lawrence). |
| Sim | 2-9 | at Sim31 | Travis Unkrich pass complete to Eric Burmiester for 5 yards to the SIM36 (Kyle Stouff). |
| Sim | 3-4 | at Sim36 | Sean Maudlin rush for 6 yards to the SIM42, 1ST DOWN SIM (Justin Rindt;Kyle Stouff). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim42 | Adam Reutzel rush for loss of 2 yards to the SIM40 (Jeremy Carver). |
| Sim | 2-12 | at Sim40 | Adam Reutzel rush for 5 yards to the SIM45 (Jason Lawrence;Nick Napoli). |
| Sim | 3-7 | at Sim45 | Adam Reutzel rush for 4 yards to the SIM49 (Nick Napoli;Colt McDonough). |
| Sim | 4-3 | at Sim49 | Bill Nelson punt 13 yards to the CUW38, downed. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 30 yards, TOP 05:04 |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw38 | CONCORDIA UNIV. (WI) drive start at 06:39. |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw38 | David White rush for loss of 3 yards to the CUW35, fumble forced by Tanner Tracy, fumble by David White recovered by CUW Ricardo Levy at CUW32 (Neil Bontrager). |
| Cuw | 2-16 | at Cuw32 | Thomas Pacchiol pass complete to Taylor Siolka for 12 yards to the CUW44. |
| Cuw | 3-4 | at Cuw44 | PENALTY CUW false start 5 yards to the CUW39. |
| Cuw | 3-9 | at Cuw39 | Thomas Pacchiol pass incomplete to Ryan Konicek (Jeff Wilkins). |
| Cuw | 4-9 | at Cuw39 | Tom Roberts punt 46 yards to the SIM15, Trent Kain return 7 yards to the SIM22 (Jesse Huff;Ryan Bott). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 1 yards, TOP 01:47 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim22 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 04:52. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim22 | Adam Reutzel rush for 4 yards to the SIM26 (Adam Schultz;Nick Napoli). |
| Sim | 2-6 | at Sim26 | Travis Unkrich pass incomplete to Aaron White (Adam Schultz). |
| Sim | 3-6 | at Sim26 | Travis Unkrich pass intercepted by Jeremy Carver at the SIM46, Jeremy Carver return 25 yards to the SIM21 (Trent Kain). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 4 yards, TOP 00:56 |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Sim21 | CONCORDIA UNIV. (WI) drive start at 03:56. |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Sim21 | Justin Lewis rush for loss of 6 yards to the SIM27 (Tim Stover;Jason Courtney). |
| Cuw | 2-16 | at Sim27 | Thomas Pacchiol rush for loss of 3 yards to the SIM30 (Luke Stover;Tanner Tracy). |
| Cuw | 3-19 | at Sim30 | Timeout Concordia Univ. (WI), clock 02:54. |
| Cuw | 3-19 | at Sim30 | Justin Lewis pass incomplete to Taylor Siolka. |
| Cuw | 4-19 | at Sim30 | Dan Winsey field goal attempt from 47 MISSED - wide left, spot at SIM35, clock 02:43. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, minus 9 yards, TOP 04:16 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim35 | Travis Unkrich pass incomplete to Mack Kimble (Dontrell Hall). |
| Sim | 2-10 | at Sim35 | Sean Maudlin rush for 3 yards to the SIM38 (Jeremy Carver;Kyle Stouff). |
| Sim | 3-7 | at Sim38 | Sean Maudlin rush for no gain to the SIM38 (Jeremy Carver;Adam Schultz), PENALTY CUW offside 4 yards to the SIM42, 1ST DOWN SIM, NO PLAY. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim42 | Mack Kimble rush for loss of 4 yards to the SIM38 (Jacob Lautenbac;Nick Napoli). |
| Sim | 2-14 | at Sim38 | Travis Unkrich pass complete to Adam Reutzel for 7 yards to the SIM45 (Justin Rindt). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 10 yards, TOP 00:20 |
| | | Simpson College 14, Concordia Univ. (WI) 3 |
| Sim | 3-7 | at Sim45 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Sim | 3-7 | at Sim45 | Travis Unkrich pass complete to Trent Kain for 14 yards to the CUW41, fumble forced by Dontrell Hall, fumble by Trent Kain recovered by CUW Dontrell Hall at CUW41. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 24 yards, TOP 00:20 |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw41 | Dontrell Hall for 49 yards to the SIM10, 1ST DOWN CUW (Travis Unkrich). |
| Cuw | 1-G | at Sim10 | CONCORDIA UNIV. (WI) drive start at 14:40. |
| Cuw | 1-G | at Sim10 | Thomas Pacchiol pass incomplete to Chris Clarke. |
| Cuw | 2-G | at Sim10 | Thomas Pacchiol pass incomplete to Ricardo Levy (Drew Lipovac). |
| Cuw | 3-G | at Sim10 | Timeout Concordia Univ. (WI), clock 14:34. |
| Cuw | 3-G | at Sim10 | Thomas Pacchiol pass incomplete to Ricardo Levy. |
| Cuw | 4-G | at Sim10 | Dan Winsey field goal attempt from 27 MISSED - wide left, spot at SIM20, clock 14:26. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 0 yards, TOP 03:06 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim20 | Travis Unkrich pass complete to Mack Kimble for 9 yards to the SIM29, out-of-bounds (Kyle Stouff). |
| Sim | 2-1 | at Sim29 | Travis Unkrich pass incomplete to Trent Kain. |
| Sim | 3-1 | at Sim29 | Sean Maudlin rush for 4 yards to the SIM33, 1ST DOWN SIM (Jason Lawrence;Jeremy Carver). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim33 | Travis Unkrich pass complete to Trent Kain for 6 yards to the SIM39 (Preston Jezek). |
| Sim | 2-4 | at Sim39 | Adam Reutzel rush for loss of 1 yard to the SIM38 (Nick Napoli). |
| Sim | 3-5 | at Sim38 | Travis Unkrich rush for no gain to the SIM38 (Jason Lawrence). |
| Sim | 4-5 | at Sim38 | Bill Nelson punt 47 yards to the CUW15, Dontrell Hall return 15 yards to the CUW30 (Cody Jensen;Tim Stover). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 18 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw30 | CONCORDIA UNIV. (WI) drive start at 11:34. |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw30 | Justin Cardarel rush for 1 yard to the CUW31 (Tim Stover;Ben Pruss). |
| Cuw | 2-9 | at Cuw31 | Thomas Pacchiol pass complete to Ricardo Levy for 10 yards to the CUW41, 1ST DOWN CUW (Lucas Kramer). |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw41 | Taylor Siolka rush for 5 yards to the CUW46 (Drew Lipovac;Kyle Disney). |
| Cuw | 2-5 | at Cuw46 | Thomas Pacchiol pass incomplete to Taylor Siolka (Ben Pruss). |
| Cuw | 3-5 | at Cuw46 | Thomas Pacchiol pass complete to Ricardo Levy for 9 yards to the SIM45, 1ST DOWN CUW, out-of-bounds (Blair Belland). |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Sim45 | Jerome Walker rush for 8 yards to the SIM37 (Kyle Disney). |
| Cuw | 2-2 | at Sim37 | Jason McClellan rush for 2 yards to the SIM35, 1ST DOWN CUW (Luke Stover;Robert Best). |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Sim35 | Thomas Pacchiol rush for 10 yards to the SIM25, 1ST DOWN CUW. |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Sim25 | PENALTY CUW false start 5 yards to the SIM30. |
| Cuw | 1-15 | at Sim30 | PENALTY CUW false start 5 yards to the SIM35. |
| Cuw | 1-20 | at Sim35 | Thomas Pacchiol sacked for loss of 5 yards to the SIM40 (Tanner Tracy). |
| Cuw | 2-25 | at Sim40 | Thomas Pacchiol pass incomplete to Ricardo Levy. |
| Cuw | 3-25 | at Sim40 | Thomas Pacchiol pass incomplete to Kristopher Zemb. |
| Cuw | 4-25 | at Sim40 | Tom Roberts punt 19 yards to the SIM21, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 30 yards, TOP 04:30 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim21 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 07:04. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim21 | Travis Unkrich pass complete to Trent Kain for 6 yards to the SIM27 (Ryan Bott;Preston Jezek). |
| Sim | 2-4 | at Sim27 | Adam Reutzel rush for 4 yards to the SIM31, 1ST DOWN SIM (Nick Napoli;Jason Lawrence). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim31 | Adam Reutzel rush for 21 yards to the CUW48, 1ST DOWN SIM, out-of-bounds (Jason Lawrence). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Cuw48 | Sean Maudlin rush for 2 yards to the CUW46 (Nick Napoli;Adam Schultz). |
| Sim | 2-8 | at Cuw46 | Sean Maudlin rush for 10 yards to the CUW36, 1ST DOWN SIM (Kyle Stouff;Travis Pagel). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Cuw36 | Sean Maudlin rush for 2 yards to the CUW34 (Colt McDonough;Eric Rusch). |
| Sim | 2-8 | at Cuw34 | Adam Reutzel rush for 2 yards to the CUW32 (Max McDonald). |
| Sim | 3-6 | at Cuw32 | Travis Unkrich rush for loss of 2 yards to the CUW34 (Patrick O'Leary;Ryan Bott). |
| Sim | 4-8 | at Cuw34 | PENALTY SIM delay of game 5 yards to the CUW39. |
| Sim | 4-13 | at Cuw39 | Adam Reutzel punt 24 yards to the CUW15, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 40 yards, TOP 05:13 |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw15 | CONCORDIA UNIV. (WI) drive start at 01:51. |
| Cuw | 1-10 | at Cuw15 | Justin Cardarel rush for 5 yards to the CUW20 (Blair Belland;Neil Bontrager). |
| Cuw | 2-5 | at Cuw20 | Jason McClellan rush for loss of 2 yards to the CUW18 (Luke Stover;Jerry Henstorf). |
| Cuw | 3-7 | at Cuw18 | Nathan Chart sacked for loss of 4 yards to the CUW14 (Jerry Henstorf). |
| Cuw | 4-11 | at Cuw14 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 01:51 |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | Simpson College 14, Concordia Univ. (WI) 3 |