| | | Brian Schaaf kickoff 55 yards to the WAR15, Spence Capitani return 26 yards to the WAR41 (Colton Calvert). |
| War | 1-10 | at War41 | Levi Helbling rush for 2 yards to the WAR43, out-of-bounds (Braden Everding). |
| War | 2-8 | at War43 | Conn Dahlstrom rush for 4 yards to the WAR47 (Ty Larsen;Mike Munson). |
| War | 3-4 | at War47 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Conn Dahlstrom for 11 yards to the SIM42, 1ST DOWN WAR (Mike Munson;Braden Everding). |
| War | 1-10 | at Sim42 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Levi Helbling for loss of 2 yards to the SIM44 (Mark Cronin). |
| War | 2-12 | at Sim44 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Levi Helbling for 17 yards to the SIM27, 1ST DOWN WAR (Mark Cronin). |
| War | 1-10 | at Sim27 | Conn Dahlstrom rush for no gain to the SIM27 (Colton Calvert). |
| War | 2-10 | at Sim27 | Conn Dahlstrom rush for 9 yards to the SIM18 (Joseph Sorenson;Colton Calvert). |
| War | 3-1 | at Sim18 | Conn Dahlstrom rush for 3 yards to the SIM15, 1ST DOWN WAR (Ted Haag;Mark Cronin). |
| War | 1-10 | at Sim15 | Brandon Sims rush for 5 yards to the SIM10 (Ted Haag;Braden Everding). |
| War | 2-5 | at Sim10 | Brandon Sims rush for 10 yards to the SIM0, 1ST DOWN WAR, TOUCHDOWN, clock 10:54. |
| | | Marcu Williams kick attempt good. |
| | | Wartburg College 7, Simpson College 0 |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 59 yards, TOP 04:06 |
| | | Trevo Finchamp kickoff 50 yards to the SIM20, Javan Freyenber return 25 yards to the SIM45 (Dominiqu Fagan;Justin Denner). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim45 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 10:47. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim45 | Michael Chia rush for 1 yard to the SIM46 (Ross Naylor). |
| Sim | 2-9 | at Sim46 | Mike Kuhn rush for 8 yards to the WAR46 (Jason Shupp). |
| Sim | 3-1 | at War46 | Taylor Nelson rush for 2 yards to the WAR44, 1ST DOWN SIM (Ross Naylor). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at War44 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Taylor Rogers for 9 yards to the WAR35 (Jared Wauters;Spence Capitani). |
| Sim | 2-1 | at War35 | Taylor Nelson rush for 1 yard to the WAR34, 1ST DOWN SIM (Jason Shupp). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at War34 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Mike Kuhn for 20 yards to the WAR14, 1ST DOWN SIM (Ryan Billings). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at War14 | Tyler Kenny rush for 9 yards to the WAR5 (Jared Wauters). |
| Sim | 2-1 | at War05 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Jake McCulley for 5 yards to the WAR0, 1ST DOWN SIM, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:53. |
| | | James Gale kick attempt good. |
| | | Simpson College 7, Wartburg College 7 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 55 yards, TOP 03:54 |
| | | Brian Schaaf kickoff 50 yards to the WAR20, Spence Capitani return 21 yards to the WAR41 (Blake Heitmeier). |
| War | 1-10 | at War41 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 06:47. |
| War | 1-10 | at War41 | Conn Dahlstrom rush for 1 yard to the WAR42 (Ty Larsen;Braden Everding). |
| War | 2-9 | at War42 | Conn Dahlstrom rush for 8 yards to the 50 yardline (Justin Bolkema;Braden Everding). |
| War | 3-1 | at War50 | PENALTY WAR holding 2 yards to the WAR48. |
| War | 3-3 | at War48 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Jacks Litterer for 4 yards to the SIM48, 1ST DOWN WAR (Mark Cronin). |
| War | 1-10 | at Sim48 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Jacks Litterer for 10 yards to the SIM38, 1ST DOWN WAR (Mark Cronin). |
| War | 1-10 | at Sim38 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Levi Helbling for no gain to the SIM38 (TJ Alger). |
| War | 2-10 | at Sim38 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Alce Smith for 15 yards to the SIM23, 1ST DOWN WAR (Mark Cronin). |
| War | 1-10 | at Sim23 | Conn Dahlstrom rush for loss of 1 yard to the SIM24 (Ty Larsen). |
| War | 2-11 | at Sim24 | Conn Dahlstrom rush for no gain to the SIM24, fumble forced by Mark Cronin, fumble by Conn Dahlstrom recovered by SIM Tyler Craig at SIM29 (Jason Shupp). |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 30 yards, TOP 03:18 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim29 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 03:29. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim29 | Taylor Nelson sacked for loss of 5 yards to the SIM24 (Jason Shupp). |
| Sim | 2-15 | at Sim24 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Jake McCulley for 22 yards to the SIM46, 1ST DOWN SIM (Jared Wauters). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim46 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Mike Kuhn. |
| Sim | 2-10 | at Sim46 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Michael Chia for 2 yards to the SIM48 (Jason Shupp). |
| Sim | 3-8 | at Sim48 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Michael Chia. |
| Sim | 4-8 | at Sim48 | Cameron Oviatt rush for loss of 21 yards to the SIM27, fumble by Cameron Oviatt recovered by WAR Team at SIM27. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, minus 2 yards, TOP 02:03 |
| War | 1-10 | at Sim27 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 01:26. |
| War | 1-10 | at Sim27 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Curt Hruska for 6 yards to the SIM21 (TJ Alger). |
| War | 2-4 | at Sim21 | Dan Stiefel pass incomplete to Logan Ruffridge (Mark Cronin). |
| War | 3-4 | at Sim21 | Dan Stiefel pass incomplete to Brandon Sims. |
| War | 4-4 | at Sim21 | Dan Stiefel pass incomplete to Levi Helbling. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 6 yards, TOP 01:02 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim21 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 00:24. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim21 | Michael Chia rush for loss of 1 yard to the SIM20 (Mark Lueschow;Justin Denner). |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 01:22 |
| | | Simpson College 7, Wartburg College 7 |
| Sim | 2-11 | at Sim20 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Sim | 2-11 | at Sim20 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Mike Kuhn. |
| Sim | 3-11 | at Sim20 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Mike Kuhn for no gain to the SIM20 (Mark Lueschow). |
| Sim | 4-11 | at Sim20 | Cameron Oviatt punt BLOCKED, recovered by WAR Mark Lueschow at SIM14 (blocked by Mark Lueschow). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 01:22 |
| War | 1-10 | at Sim14 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 14:02. |
| War | 1-10 | at Sim14 | PENALTY WAR personal foul 3 yards to the SIM17. |
| War | 1-13 | at Sim17 | Brandon Sims rush for 7 yards to the SIM10 (Mark Cronin). |
| War | 2-6 | at Sim10 | Brandon Sims rush for 6 yards to the SIM4, 1ST DOWN WAR (Tyler Craig). |
| War | 1-G | at Sim04 | Brandon Sims rush for 3 yards to the SIM1 (Ben Borland). |
| War | 2-G | at Sim01 | Dan Stiefel rush for no gain to the SIM1 (Ben Borland). |
| War | 3-G | at Sim01 | PENALTY SIM Encroachment 0 yards to the SIM1. |
| War | 3-G | at Sim01 | Brandon Sims rush for 1 yard to the SIM0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 11:47. |
| | | Marcu Williams kick attempt failed. |
| | | Wartburg College 13, Simpson College 7 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 14 yards, TOP 02:15 |
| | | Trevo Finchamp kickoff 64 yards to the SIM6, Mike Kuhn return 16 yards to the SIM22 (Ryan Billings). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim22 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 11:41. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim22 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Ben Coy for 26 yards to the SIM48, 1ST DOWN SIM (Justin Denner). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim48 | Michael Chia rush for 27 yards to the WAR25, 1ST DOWN SIM (Jared Wauters). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at War25 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Jake McCulley for 9 yards to the WAR16 (Jared Wauters). |
| Sim | 2-1 | at War16 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Mike Kuhn (Spence Capitani). |
| Sim | 3-1 | at War16 | Michael Chia rush for 2 yards to the WAR14, 1ST DOWN SIM (Ryan Billings). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at War14 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Michael Chia for 1 yard to the WAR13 (Mark Lueschow). |
| Sim | 2-9 | at War13 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Michael Chia. |
| Sim | 3-9 | at War13 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Taylor Rogers for 8 yards to the WAR5 (Garrett McGrane). |
| Sim | 4-1 | at War05 | Timeout Simpson College, clock 08:17. |
| Sim | 4-1 | at War05 | Taylor Nelson rush for 1 yard to the WAR4, 1ST DOWN SIM (Mark Lueschow;Ryan Billings). |
| Sim | 1-G | at War04 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Taylor Rogers for 4 yards to the WAR0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 07:48. |
| | | James Gale kick attempt good. |
| | | Simpson College 14, Wartburg College 13 |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 78 yards, TOP 03:53 |
| | | Brian Schaaf kickoff 36 yards to the WAR34, fair catch by Johnny Lopez. |
| War | 1-10 | at War34 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 07:48. |
| War | 1-10 | at War34 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Jacks Litterer for 4 yards to the WAR38 (Ty Larsen). |
| War | 2-6 | at War38 | Dan Stiefel pass incomplete to Levi Helbling. |
| War | 3-6 | at War38 | Dan Stiefel pass incomplete to Levi Helbling. |
| War | 4-6 | at War38 | Robby Salmon punt 53 yards to the SIM9, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 4 yards, TOP 02:31 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim09 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 06:43. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim09 | Michael Chia rush for 1 yard to the SIM10 (Jason Shupp). |
| Sim | 2-9 | at Sim10 | Mike Kuhn rush for 2 yards to the SIM12 (Garrett McGrane). |
| Sim | 3-7 | at Sim12 | PENALTY SIM holding declined. |
| Sim | 3-7 | at Sim12 | Taylor Nelson sacked for loss of 8 yards to the SIM4 (Ross Naylor). |
| Sim | 4-15 | at Sim04 | Cameron Oviatt rush for loss of 4 yards to the SIM0 (Garrett McGrane), Team safety, clock 05:17. |
| | | Wartburg College 15, Simpson College 14 |
| Sim | 1-G | at Sim20 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 05:17, SIM ball on SIM20. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| | | Brian Schaaf kickoff 38 yards to the WAR42, Jacks Litterer return 7 yards to the WAR49 (Tyler Craig). |
| War | 1-10 | at War49 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 05:10. |
| War | 1-10 | at War49 | Brandon Sims rush for loss of 4 yards to the WAR45 (Ty Larsen). |
| War | 2-14 | at War45 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Levi Helbling for 19 yards to the SIM36, 1ST DOWN WAR (Caleb Wetherell). |
| War | 1-10 | at Sim36 | Brandon Sims rush for 5 yards to the SIM31 (Tyler Craig). |
| War | 2-5 | at Sim31 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Levi Helbling for 16 yards to the SIM15, 1ST DOWN WAR (Colton Calvert). |
| War | 1-10 | at Sim15 | Brandon Sims rush for 5 yards to the SIM10 (Mark Cronin). |
| War | 2-5 | at Sim10 | Brandon Sims rush for loss of 1 yard to the SIM11 (Tyler Craig). |
| War | 3-6 | at Sim11 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Levi Helbling for no gain to the SIM11 (Colton Calvert). |
| War | 4-6 | at Sim11 | Timeout Simpson College, clock 01:22. |
| War | 4-6 | at Sim11 | Brandon Sims rush for 5 yards to the SIM6 (Brandon Abernat). |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 45 yards, TOP 03:53 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim06 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 01:17. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim06 | Michael Chia rush for no gain to the SIM6, fumble forced by Mark Lueschow, fumble by Michael Chia recovered by WAR Mark Lueschow at SIM3. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 3 yards, TOP 00:07 |
| War | 1-G | at Sim03 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 01:10. |
| War | 1-G | at Sim03 | Brandon Sims rush for 3 yards to the SIM0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 01:05. |
| | | Marcu Williams kick attempt failed (fumbled). |
| | | Wartburg College 21, Simpson College 14 |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 3 yards, TOP 00:05 |
| | | Trevo Finchamp kickoff 50 yards to the SIM20, Mike Kuhn return 21 yards to the SIM41 (Joey Naig). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim41 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 00:57. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim41 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Mike Kuhn for 5 yards to the SIM46, out-of-bounds. |
| Sim | 2-5 | at Sim46 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Javan Freyenber for loss of 6 yards to the SIM40 (Mark Lueschow). |
| Sim | 3-11 | at Sim40 | Taylor Nelson rush for 20 yards to the WAR40, 1ST DOWN SIM (Martin Hyatte). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at War40 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Taylor Rogers (Spence Capitani). |
| Sim | 2-10 | at War40 | Taylor Nelson rush for no gain to the WAR40, out-of-bounds. |
| Sim | 3-10 | at War40 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Mike Kuhn. |
| Sim | 4-10 | at War40 | Taylor Nelson rush for 10 yards to the WAR30, 1ST DOWN SIM, out-of-bounds. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at War30 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 29 yards, TOP 00:57 |
| | | Wartburg College 21, Simpson College 14 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at War30 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, WAR ball on WAR30. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 29 yards, TOP 00:57 |
| | | Trevo Finchamp kickoff 61 yards to the SIM9, Javan Freyenber return 14 yards to the SIM23 (Ryan Billings). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim23 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 14:52. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim23 | Tyler Kenny rush for 1 yard to the SIM24 (Mark Lueschow). |
| Sim | 2-9 | at Sim24 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Ben Coy. |
| Sim | 3-9 | at Sim24 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Michael Chia. |
| Sim | 4-9 | at Sim24 | Cameron Oviatt punt 29 yards to the WAR47, Jacks Litterer return 6 yards to the SIM47 (DJ Bennett). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 1 yards, TOP 00:58 |
| War | 1-10 | at Sim47 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 13:54. |
| War | 1-10 | at Sim47 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Curt Hruska for 24 yards to the SIM23, 1ST DOWN WAR (Adam Bobier;Braden Everding). |
| War | 1-10 | at Sim23 | Brandon Sims rush for 1 yard to the SIM22 (Brenton Minish;Ted Haag). |
| War | 2-9 | at Sim22 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Curt Hruska for 16 yards to the SIM6, 1ST DOWN WAR (Braden Everding). |
| War | 1-G | at Sim06 | Brandon Sims rush for 3 yards to the SIM3 (Mark Cronin;Adam Bobier). |
| War | 2-G | at Sim03 | Brandon Sims rush for 3 yards to the SIM0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 12:00. |
| | | Marcu Williams kick attempt good. |
| | | Wartburg College 28, Simpson College 14 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 47 yards, TOP 01:54 |
| | | Trevo Finchamp kickoff 57 yards to the SIM13, Javan Freyenber return 24 yards to the SIM37 (Dominiqu Fagan). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim37 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 11:53. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim37 | PENALTY WAR roughing passer 24 yards to the WAR39, 1ST DOWN SIM. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at War39 | Taylor Nelson rush for 3 yards to the WAR36, out-of-bounds. |
| Sim | 2-7 | at War36 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Alex McCarty for 7 yards to the WAR29, 1ST DOWN SIM (Jared Wauters). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at War29 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Ben Coy for 4 yards to the WAR25 (Jason Shupp). |
| Sim | 2-6 | at War25 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Taylor Rogers for 5 yards to the WAR20 (David Hoehne). |
| Sim | 3-1 | at War20 | Taylor Nelson rush for 2 yards to the WAR18, 1ST DOWN SIM (Jason Shupp). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at War18 | PENALTY SIM false start 5 yards to the WAR23. |
| Sim | 1-15 | at War23 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Taylor Rogers. |
| Sim | 2-15 | at War23 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Mike Kuhn for loss of 2 yards to the WAR25 (David Hoehne). |
| Sim | 3-17 | at War25 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Taylor Rogers. |
| Sim | 4-17 | at War25 | Taylor Nelson sacked for loss of 1 yard to the WAR26 (Matt Tschetter). |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 37 yards, TOP 03:55 |
| War | 1-10 | at War26 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 07:58. |
| War | 1-10 | at War26 | Brandon Sims rush for 1 yard to the WAR27 (Mark Cronin). |
| War | 2-9 | at War27 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Curt Hruska for 8 yards to the WAR35 (Jarrod Schott). |
| War | 3-1 | at War35 | Reese Thompson rush for 2 yards to the WAR37, 1ST DOWN WAR (Mike Munson). |
| War | 1-10 | at War37 | Dan Stiefel pass incomplete to Curt Hruska. |
| War | 2-10 | at War37 | Reese Thompson rush for loss of 1 yard to the WAR36 (Tyler Craig;Braden Everding). |
| War | 3-11 | at War36 | Dan Stiefel pass incomplete to Curt Hruska (Mark Cronin). |
| War | 4-11 | at War36 | PENALTY SIM roughing the kicker 15 yards to the SIM49, 1ST DOWN WAR. |
| War | 1-10 | at Sim49 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Levi Helbling for 10 yards to the SIM39, 1ST DOWN WAR, out-of-bounds. |
| War | 1-10 | at Sim39 | Brandon Sims rush for no gain to the SIM39 (Brenton Minish). |
| War | 2-10 | at Sim39 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Levi Helbling for 7 yards to the SIM32 (TJ Alger). |
| War | 3-3 | at Sim32 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Curt Hruska for 22 yards to the SIM10, 1ST DOWN WAR (Colton Calvert). |
| War | 1-G | at Sim10 | PENALTY WAR holding 9 yards to the SIM19. |
| War | 1-G | at Sim19 | PENALTY WAR holding 10 yards to the SIM29. |
| War | 1-G | at Sim29 | Dan Stiefel rush for 4 yards to the SIM25, out-of-bounds. |
| War | 2-G | at Sim25 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Brandon Sims for 1 yard to the SIM24 (Ted Haag). |
| War | 3-G | at Sim24 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Levi Helbling for 16 yards to the SIM8 (Jarrod Schott). |
| War | 4-G | at Sim08 | Marcu Williams field goal attempt from 25 GOOD, clock 01:45. |
| | | Wartburg College 31, Simpson College 14 |
| | | Drive: 14 plays, 66 yards, TOP 06:13 |
| | | Trevo Finchamp kickoff 46 yards to the SIM24, Mike Kuhn return 10 yards to the SIM34 (Andrew Putz). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim34 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 01:40. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim34 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Ben Coy for 4 yards to the SIM38, out-of-bounds. |
| Sim | 2-6 | at Sim38 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Ben Coy for 11 yards to the SIM49, 1ST DOWN SIM (Martin Hyatte). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim49 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Ben Coy. |
| Sim | 2-10 | at Sim49 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Mike Kuhn for 17 yards to the WAR34, 1ST DOWN SIM (Jared Wauters). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at War34 | Michael Chia rush for 19 yards to the WAR15, 1ST DOWN SIM (Spence Capitani). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at War15 | Michael Chia rush for 2 yards to the WAR13 (Martin Hyatte). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 53 yards, TOP 02:10 |
| | | Wartburg College 31, Simpson College 14 |
| Sim | 2-8 | at War13 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Sim | 2-8 | at War13 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Mike Kuhn for 7 yards to the WAR6, out-of-bounds. |
| Sim | 3-1 | at War06 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Michael Chia for 6 yards to the WAR0, 1ST DOWN SIM, TOUCHDOWN, clock 14:30. |
| | | James Gale kick attempt good. |
| | | Wartburg College 31, Simpson College 21 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 66 yards, TOP 02:10 |
| | | Brian Schaaf kickoff 58 yards to the WAR12, Spence Capitani return 16 yards to the WAR28 (Brandon Abernat;Matt Gregory). |
| War | 1-10 | at War28 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 14:23. |
| War | 1-10 | at War28 | Reese Thompson rush for 3 yards to the WAR31 (Justin Bolkema). |
| War | 2-7 | at War31 | Reese Thompson rush for 2 yards to the WAR33 (Tanner Klein;Mark Cronin). |
| War | 3-5 | at War33 | PENALTY WAR false start (Jacob Schrom) 5 yards to the WAR28. |
| War | 3-10 | at War28 | Dan Stiefel pass incomplete to Curt Hruska. |
| War | 4-10 | at War28 | Robby Salmon punt 55 yards to the SIM17, Mike Kuhn return 4 yards to the SIM21 (Martin Hyatte). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 01:58 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim21 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 12:25. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim21 | Taylor Nelson rush for 9 yards to the SIM30 (Jared Wauters). |
| Sim | 2-1 | at Sim30 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Mike Kuhn for 2 yards to the SIM32, 1ST DOWN SIM (Garrett McGrane;David Hoehne). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim32 | PENALTY SIM false start 5 yards to the SIM27. |
| Sim | 1-15 | at Sim27 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Jake McCulley for 4 yards to the SIM31 (Jason Shupp;Mark Lueschow). |
| Sim | 2-11 | at Sim31 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Michael Chia for 19 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN SIM (Jared Wauters). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim50 | PENALTY SIM substitution infraction 5 yards to the SIM45. |
| Sim | 1-15 | at Sim45 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Michael Chia (Martin Hyatte). |
| Sim | 2-15 | at Sim45 | Ben Coy rush for 16 yards to the WAR39, 1ST DOWN SIM (Spence Capitani). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at War39 | PENALTY SIM holding 10 yards to the WAR49. |
| Sim | 1-20 | at War49 | PENALTY SIM intentional grounding (Taylor Nelson) 11 yards to the SIM40. |
| Sim | 2-31 | at Sim40 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Michael Chia for 20 yards to the WAR40 (Ross Naylor). |
| Sim | 3-11 | at War40 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Taylor Rogers. |
| Sim | 4-11 | at War40 | PENALTY SIM delay of game 5 yards to the WAR45. |
| Sim | 4-16 | at War45 | Cameron Oviatt punt 29 yards to the WAR16, downed. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 34 yards, TOP 04:31 |
| War | 1-10 | at War16 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 07:54. |
| War | 1-10 | at War16 | Brandon Sims rush for no gain to the WAR16 (Braden Everding). |
| War | 2-10 | at War16 | Brandon Sims rush for 30 yards to the WAR46, 1ST DOWN WAR (Colton Calvert). |
| War | 1-10 | at War46 | Brandon Sims rush for 1 yard to the WAR47 (Brenton Minish). |
| War | 2-9 | at War47 | PENALTY WAR holding 9 yards to the WAR38. |
| War | 2-18 | at War38 | Dan Stiefel pass complete to Levi Helbling for 7 yards to the WAR45 (Colton Calvert). |
| War | 3-11 | at War45 | Brandon Sims rush for 6 yards to the SIM49 (Ted Haag). |
| War | 4-5 | at Sim49 | Timeout Wartburg College, clock 04:03. |
| War | 4-5 | at Sim49 | Robby Salmon punt 49 yards to the SIM0, touchback. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 35 yards, TOP 03:59 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim20 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 03:55. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim20 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Javan Freyenber. |
| Sim | 2-10 | at Sim20 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Javan Freyenber for 8 yards to the SIM28 (Jason Shupp). |
| Sim | 3-2 | at Sim28 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Javan Freyenber. |
| Sim | 4-2 | at Sim28 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Javan Freyenber for 8 yards to the SIM36, 1ST DOWN SIM (David Hoehne). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim36 | PENALTY SIM false start 5 yards to the SIM31. |
| Sim | 1-15 | at Sim31 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Javan Freyenber for 16 yards to the SIM47, 1ST DOWN SIM (David Hoehne). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at Sim47 | PENALTY SIM false start 5 yards to the SIM42. |
| Sim | 1-15 | at Sim42 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Taylor Rogers. |
| Sim | 2-15 | at Sim42 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Taylor Rogers for 13 yards to the WAR45 (David Hoehne). |
| Sim | 3-2 | at War45 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Mike Kuhn for 13 yards to the WAR32, 1ST DOWN SIM (David Hoehne). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at War32 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Taylor Rogers for 27 yards to the WAR5, 1ST DOWN SIM (Jared Wauters). |
| Sim | 1-G | at War05 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Brad Vogel. |
| Sim | 2-G | at War05 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Ben Coy. |
| Sim | 3-G | at War05 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Mike Kuhn. |
| Sim | 4-G | at War05 | James Gale field goal attempt from 22 GOOD, clock 01:40. |
| | | Wartburg College 31, Simpson College 24 |
| | | Drive: 13 plays, 75 yards, TOP 02:15 |
| | | Brian Schaaf kickoff 44 yards to the WAR26, downed. |
| War | 1-10 | at War26 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 01:40. |
| War | 1-10 | at War26 | Reese Thompson rush for 2 yards to the WAR28 (Ty Larsen;Braden Everding). |
| War | 2-8 | at War28 | Timeout Simpson College, clock 01:34. |
| War | 2-8 | at War28 | Reese Thompson rush for 2 yards to the WAR30 (Tyler Craig;Ted Haag). |
| War | 3-6 | at War30 | Timeout Simpson College, clock 01:27. |
| War | 3-6 | at War30 | Dan Stiefel rush for 4 yards to the WAR34, out-of-bounds. |
| War | 4-2 | at War34 | Robby Salmon punt 9 yards to the WAR43, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 8 yards, TOP 00:33 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at War43 | SIMPSON COLLEGE drive start at 01:07. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at War43 | Taylor Nelson pass incomplete to Taylor Rogers. |
| Sim | 2-10 | at War43 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Mike Kuhn for 4 yards to the WAR39 (Jason Shupp). |
| Sim | 3-6 | at War39 | PENALTY WAR pass interference 5 yards to the WAR34, 1ST DOWN SIM. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at War34 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Taylor Rogers for 11 yards to the WAR23, 1ST DOWN SIM (Spence Capitani). |
| Sim | 1-10 | at War23 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Mike Kuhn for 14 yards to the WAR9, 1ST DOWN SIM, out-of-bounds. |
| Sim | 1-G | at War09 | PENALTY SIM false start 5 yards to the WAR14. |
| Sim | 1-G | at War14 | PENALTY WAR pass interference 4 yards to the WAR10, 1ST DOWN SIM. |
| Sim | 1-G | at War10 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Taylor Rogers for 10 yards to the WAR0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:11. |
| Sim | 1-G | at War03 | Timeout Simpson College, clock 00:11. |
| | | James Gale kick attempt good. |
| | | Simpson College 31, Wartburg College 31 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 43 yards, TOP 00:56 |
| | | Brian Schaaf kickoff 40 yards to the WAR30, Jacks Litterer return 0 yards to the WAR30. |
| War | 1-10 | at War30 | WARTBURG COLLEGE drive start at 00:08. |
| War | 1-10 | at War30 | Team rush for loss of 1 yard to the WAR29. |
| War | 2-11 | at War29 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 00:08 |
| | | Simpson College 31, Wartburg College 31 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 25 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| | | Simpson College 38, Wartburg College 37 |
| War | 2-11 | at War29 | Start of OT quarter, clock 15:00. |
| War | 2-11 | at War29 | Change of possession, SIM ball on WAR25, 1st and 10. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, minus 1 yards, TOP 00:08 |
| Sim | 1-10 | at War25 | SIM ball on WAR25. |
| Sim | 1-10 | at War25 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Ben Coy for 15 yards to the WAR10, 1ST DOWN SIM (Spence Capitani). |
| Sim | 1-G | at War10 | Taylor Nelson pass complete to Taylor Rogers for 10 yards to the WAR0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 15:00. |
| | | James Gale kick attempt good. |
| | | Simpson College 38, Wartburg College 31 |
| Sim | 1-G | at Sim30 | WAR ball on SIM25. |
| War | 1-G | at Sim25 | Change of possession, WAR ball on SIM25, 1st and 10. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 25 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| War | 1-10 | at Sim25 | Brandon Sims rush for 11 yards to the SIM14, 1ST DOWN WAR (Mark Cronin). |
| War | 1-10 | at Sim14 | Dan Stiefel rush for 3 yards to the SIM11, out-of-bounds. |
| War | 2-7 | at Sim11 | Reese Thompson rush for 7 yards to the SIM4, 1ST DOWN WAR (Colton Calvert). |
| War | 1-G | at Sim04 | Reese Thompson rush for 4 yards to the SIM0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 15:00. |
| | | Marcu Williams kick attempt failed (blocked) (blocked by Brenton Minish). |
| | | Simpson College 38, Wartburg College 37 |
| | | Wartburg wins coin toss, defers to the second half. |
| | | OT: Wartburg wins coin toss, defer. Simpson choses north goal. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 25 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| | | Simpson College 38, Wartburg College 37 |